Skip to Content

A Pink Car Seat for My Son?

Baby A’s car seat will support him until he reaches 22 pounds, but he’s growing like a weed and is currently in the 90th percentile for height and the 85 percentile for weight. Needless to say he’ll outgrow his original car seat much faster than your average baby.

Rather than waiting for him to outgrow his current seat I decided to begin searching for a new one now. I figured I’d have a head start that would help me find a really good bargain. According to the experts car seats are one item you should never buy used. The reason being that you can’t guarantee a used car seat has never been in a car accident before.

So I scoured the Internet for new ones and found a few good deals on Britax models. Late one night, long after I should have been asleep, I found a really great sale at Target.

I was clicking around on all sorts of things. Adding them to my cart and then removing them after further review. Well as some point in the night I found a much less inexpensive Britax model that had outstanding ratings, so I did what any sleep deprived mother would do I pulled out my credit card and purchased it.

A few days later a large package arrived outside my door and sure enough when I opened the box I found my car seat had arrived. There was just one problem. Inside the box I found a bright pink, flowered seat in a place of the black and gray one I expected to find.

I thought for sure the store made a mistake but when I went back and looked at my order I realized I’d accidentally ordered the wrong car seat for my son. While I did pay just over $100 for this seat, which is a really good bargain, it is undoubtedly pink! Similar seats for boys are at least $60 more.

So here’s the question. Do I stick with the bargain and keep the car seat at this unbelievable price or do I return it simply because it’s pink? I must admit it seems rather crazy to pay more just to get it in a different color. On the other hand it seems a little crazy to buy a pink car seat for my infant son just because it’s cheap!

*Note – I am not concerned about my son’s reaction to the pink car seat. He sleeps in a pink blanket every night. I was more frustrated by my own mistake and I think slightly concerned that other people would recognize my cheapness, but in saying that out loud I realize that I really shouldn’t care what people think.

One Frugal Girl

Monday 5th of March 2012

Interesting article. I read about that book (I am a U of Maryland alumn) the day after I wrote this post. Fascinating how things have changed. Baby A is never mistaken for a girl, (well once), he looks all boy, but I know a lot of people who dress their children in the expected colors just so they don't have to correct people.

Ruby Leigh

Friday 2nd of March 2012

I did not have a major problem with this post - like the earlier commenters... but I though I would add just use a blanket to shield the pink - if you are concerned.

Newlyweds on a Budget

Thursday 1st of March 2012

wow i didn't realize this post would elicit such strong comments, but as for my two cents, i would keep it just because it's cheaper! babies are expensive as it is.


Monday 27th of February 2012

My only concern of it for you (from me to you!) is if there is a reason the other color is more expensive. Is it made a different way or anything like that? (Remember, I'm not a mom, so I don't know these things lol). but I wouldn't got a good deal, and HERE is the place to brag about it girl! Don't worry what others will think....If I had the option to get a cheaper one and it was the color of yours and I had a boy I'd be bragging that I saved $60 on it! lol. But that's just me. I've grown a thick skin over the years and I really don't care what people think of me, which is what I think you're going through, what others will think. It takes time, but I'm sure being a new mommy you will be able to learn quickly not to give a toot about what others think of you...march to the beat of your own drummer...join's FUN :)

One Frugal Girl

Monday 27th of February 2012

There are some slight differences between the models, but nothing necessary. Certainly nothing in terms of safety or anything. There are nicer models out there with lots more features but they are upwards of $300. It's funny in many ways I don't care what people think. Maybe because I'm a new mom I haven't gained confidence yet in this area.


Saturday 25th of February 2012

I'm with commenter #1 (I don't think I've commented before, either). Who cares what color it is? He certainly doesn't. The only question that matters is "is it safe?". Are you afraid of what other people will think? Does it really make you uncomfortable to put a boy in something pink? I think it's an awesome example of not living your life according to society's expectations - you do that already by living a frugal life, which your kids will pick up on. Give them another example, like this one.

One Frugal Girl

Saturday 25th of February 2012

I do think I was worried about what other people would think. Not that my son would sit in a pink seat. See note added in the post above. Thanks for commenting.